In the race to combat climate change and transition to a carbon-neutral future, hydrogen has emerged as a cornerstone of sustainable energy strategies. Due to climate measures, experts predict that the demand for hydrogen will quintuple by 2050. While most of the attention has been directed towards green hydrogen, produced using renewable energy, a new contender is quietly entering the conversation: white hydrogen. Unlike its green, blue, or gray counterparts, white hydrogen is naturally occurring, found underground, and requires no industrial production. But is it the game-changer it appears to be?
A discovery with potential
White hydrogen, also referred to as natural hydrogen, is formed deep within the Earth’s crust through natural processes such as the interaction of water with certain rocks, including iron-rich minerals. Unlike green hydrogen, which requires electrolysis, or blue hydrogen, which involves carbon capture technologies, white hydrogen exists in nature without the need for human interference to create it. Early research indicates that it could be an abundant, renewable source of energy with little environmental footprint.
In the village of Bourakébougou, located in southwestern Mali, electricity has been generated using natural hydrogen from the ground since 2011. According to an international study led by Professor Alain Prinzhofer of the Institut de Physique du Globe de Paris, the natural hydrogen reserves in the earth are much larger than previously thought. The hydrogen basin's diameter is 150 kilometers, rather than 8 (as was first suggested). Moreover, it contains significant amounts of hydrogen that could be sustainably and relatively easily exploited. This extraction would also be much cheaper than hydrogen production in factories, whether using fossil fuels or green electricity.
The excitement surrounding white hydrogen stems from its potential abundance and availability. Some estimates indicate that its reserves could last for centuries, making it a seemingly endless energy source. Geological research in the Netherlands has pointed to possible white hydrogen reservoirs, especially in regions with salt domes or coal seams like Limburg. Such recent findings in the Netherlands, but also in other areas like the Caribbean, have further fuelled interest in tapping into these reserves. If its viability is confirmed, white hydrogen could complement other renewable energy sources and contribute to meeting global energy needs sustainably.
The advantages of white hydrogen
In addition to its abundance, the environmental profile of white hydrogen provides a compelling argument for the newly found potential source of energy. As a result of its natural occurrence, extracting it requires minimal energy as opposed to production-intensive processes associated with green or blue hydrogen. Additionally, its carbon footprint is negligible, as it does not involve fossil fuels or generate greenhouse gas emissions during extraction.
Another advantage lies in its potential economic feasibility. If white hydrogen can be tapped efficiently, it could eliminate the need for expensive hydrogen production infrastructure. Moreover, the discovery of domestic reserves could reduce reliance on imported energy, enhancing energy security for many nations. In the French Lotharingen, researchers found reservoirs filled with about 46 million tons of white hydrogen . Regions in the Alps, New Caledonia, and the Pyrenees are also being explored for white hydrogen. Additionally, researchers are searching for white hydrogen in Spain, Germany, Kosovo, Iceland, Finland, Sweden, Poland, Serbia, Norway, Ukraine, Russia, and Kazakhstan.
Challenges and uncertainties
Thus, given the sum of these advantages of white hydrogen, expectations are high. However, some concerns remain. Definitive information on the global quantity of white hydrogen and where its precise locations are still lacking. As a result, Ad van Wijk, a hydrogen expert from the Netherlands and part-time professor of Future Energy Systems at TU Delft, remains cautious in his optimism. His wariness is rooted in the fact that white hydrogen is still somewhat uncharted territory. van Wijk expresses concerns about the scalability of its use and expects white hydrogen to only have a marginal impact on the energy transition. He believes that hydrogen is still best produced using water and green electricity.
Finally, there is the question of competitiveness. The hydrogen economy is already heavily invested in green hydrogen as the ‘clean’ hydrogen of choice. With governments and private companies pouring billions into green hydrogen infrastructure, white hydrogen must prove itself not only environmentally but also economically superior to justify a shift in focus.
A realistic vision for the future
The discovery of white hydrogen is undoubtedly exciting, but it is essential to approach its potential with balanced optimism. While it may not singlehandedly solve the world’s energy challenges, it could play an important role in diversifying the hydrogen landscape and enhancing global energy resilience.
For white hydrogen to fulfill its promise, a multi-pronged effort is needed. Governments and research institutions must invest in exploration and extraction technologies, while the private sector can help scale operations and develop commercial applications. International cooperation will also be crucial, as the benefits of white hydrogen can only be fully realized through shared knowledge and coordinated action. Explorations in the Dutch subsurface and the Caribbean region suggest promising white hydrogen reserves, with local governments and researchers collaborating to assess its scalability for energy production.
In the end, white hydrogen is not a silver bullet, but it presents a valuable addition to the portfolio of sustainable energy solutions. White hydrogen, unlike its manufactured counterparts, could serve as an almost inexhaustible energy resource, provided challenges around detection and extraction are resolved. With careful monitoring and continued innovation, it could provide a cleaner, more secure energy future. Whether it becomes a cornerstone of global energy systems or remains a niche solution depends on the next steps taken by scientists, policymakers, and industry leaders. For now, white hydrogen remains a beacon of hope, illuminating the path toward a more sustainable tomorrow. Shall we?
This article is part of The Outside World Formula created by ftrprf
For organizations, it’s pivotal to thoroughly understand what is happening in society. We help companies generate comprehensive insights into societal change and its potential effects on their strategy and operations, both negative and positive. With actionable societal insights, courageous plans, and a can-do mentality, we connect the outside world to your company's strategy. For these outside-world insights, we use a rigorous methodology that includes data processing, quantitative and qualitative analysis, and a thorough review process to ensure the accuracy and consistency of our findings. This article was written based on our monitoring of the theme ‘the energy transition’.
For more information, please contact info@ftrprf.com.
Sources:
2. “Witte Waterstof: Hoop of Hype?” De Ingenieur, accessed January 21, 2025.
3. “15 Dingen Die Je Moet Weten over Waterstof,” TNO, accessed January 21, 2025.
4. “Onderzoek naar Witte Waterstof in Nederland en Antillen,” Change Inc., accessed January 21, 2025.