Interview with Dirk Schoenmaker
Dirk Schoenmaker is a Professor of Banking and Finance at Rotterdam School of Management, Erasmus University Rotterdam. He previously held policy roles at the Bank of England and the Dutch Ministry of Finance, and served as dean of the Duisenberg School of Finance. His work reflects a longstanding commitment to solving societal challenges. Together with Willem Schramade, he co-authored Corporate Finance for Long-Term Value (2023), which presents integrated value as an approach to company valuation that brings a company's financial, social and environmental value together.
In this interview, Schoenmaker explains why long-term returns depend on healthy social and ecological foundations, and how integrated value can inform business decisions. He also reflects on the ethical limits of monetisation, fairness to future generations, and his hope that responsible business will become the standard.
What motivated you to redefine traditional economic value, was there a specific moment that made you realize the financial system needed a new framework?
There was a specific moment, about eleven years ago, where I realised that nature is circular and that it can function well without our interference. Yet companies often have a negative impact on nature and disrupt ecosystems, undermining the foundations of our own lives. That is why we need to look at a company's ecological impact alongside its financial performance. The social side is also very important: everyone should be able to share in a company's benefits, rather than just a few people.
I often explain it as a wedding cake. Ecology is at the bottom, society comes next, and the economy sits on top. Society needs an economy to organize itself, but the ecological and social foundations are more important. The economy depends on them.
How does integrated value fundamentally differ from traditional financial theory?
The good news is that the theory remains the same; we simply cast the net wider. We bring social and environmental effects into the valuation alongside financial value.
As my co-author Willem often stresses, the aim is to connect financial value with social and ecological impact. We acknowledge that a business will not survive without making a profit, but its long-term prospects also depend on how it affects society and nature. Many people work on these areas separately. Our contribution is to bring them together.
How do we measure and put a price tag on things that are inherently difficult to quantify, such as biodiversity, clean air, or social cohesion? And why is it important to try to quantify these issues, even though they are hard to get precisely right?
Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) ratings involve a lot of measurement. But they use different scoring systems and serve different purposes, which make their results difficult to compare. If you want to talk business, you have to use the language of business: cash flows and euros. Expressing social and environmental effects in monetary terms allows us to consider them alongside financial performance when making decisions.
To do this, we use shadow prices: estimates of an effect’s value or cost to society, informed by scientific evidence. In health, for example, quality-adjusted life years account for both the length and quality of life to assess a new drug. For carbon emissions, we do not use the European emissions trading price of about €75 per tonne, but the real societal cost of about €300 per tonne. We can then multiply the emissions by that shadow price to quantify the environmental cost.
What are the challenging aspects to quantifying these issues?
There are philosophical questions behind this. First, it is controversial what you can monetize. Severe issues like sexual harassment or human rights violations can never be justified or 'bought off'. Placing a shadow price on them helps to quantify the severity of the harm done.
The defence sector illustrates the difficulty of drawing these moral boundaries. Take Rheinmetall, the German company making defence equipment. On one side, defence provides security; on the other, weapons kill people. As economists, we are not equipped to decide what is ethically acceptable or where society should draw the line. There is a personal and ethical element to these judgements,which we decided not to monetize. Different people draw the line at different places.
A second philosophical issue is how we treat the future. Ecological issues, such as carbon emissions and toxic pollution, are often seen as problems of tomorrow. In finance, we use discounting to calculate what future costs and benefits are worth in today's terms. The discount rate determines how much less they count, and the higher the rate, the less importance a future cost carries in today's calculations. With high rates, such as 8-10%, damage expected decades from now can appear relatively small in today's calculations. This can lead to underinvestment in solutions and raises questions of fairness to future generations.
When governments assess projects, they use a social discount rate to weigh future costs and benefits. One part of this rate, called “pure time preference”, reflects whether we give less importance to people’s wellbeing simply because it occurs later. Setting it at 0% means that an equal improvement in wellbeing matters as much in fifty years as it does today. The rate also accounts for expected economic growth, which we might assume to be 2% a year. If future generations are wealthier, the same financial cost may be easier for them to bear. With a low overall discount rate, preventing damage decades from now carries more weight in decisions about investment today.
Private finance often uses high discount rates, which can make long-term social and environmental harm look less significant in today’s calculations. In our approach, we use lower discount rates for the social and environmental effects. The resulting valuations can be large, but so are the problems we are trying to address. That is why bringing social discounting into finance is important. As the famous climate economist, Nick Stern, has argued, failing to use a low discount rate does a disservice to the climate. That makes it an ethical issue within our discipline, and I fully agree with it, we cannot ignore this important issue.
Why should purely profit-driven investors care about integrated value, and is there a proven financial case for looking beyond standard financial returns?
I have two answers. The first, which Willem Schramade and I discuss in our textbook Corporate Finance for Long-Term Value, is looking long term and having a proper definition of risk. Many calculations assume business as usual. But the world is dynamic. If the emissions trading price rises from €75 to €300, which I expect it eventually will, an investment that is profitable today at €75 may no longer be profitable. Costs previously borne by society would then become costs for the business.
This also changes how we understand risk. Our notion of risk is too focused on the historical volatility of short-term returns, when it should also consider longer-term social and environmental pressures. Biodiversity loss, climate change and water shortages have featured in the World Economic Forum’s risk surveys for years. In the Netherlands, the nitrogen crisis in agriculture illustrates how ecological pressures can affect businesses. I see planetary boundaries as a compass for the future: if we take them seriously, we can identify where scarcity is emerging. When we include these longer-term risks in our calculations, many businesses that look profitable today no longer do.
The second answer is more fundamental. Pension funds and insurance companies are long-term investors. For someone in their twenties, retirement is another forty years away, so the investment horizon can be forty to seventy years. We cannot time risks precisely. If and when oil businesses become unprofitable, refineries may have no resale value. If you wait until that happens, you can lose the full value of your investment.
Ultimately, these investors depend on the real economy to deliver future returns. That requires healthy social and ecological foundations. Ignoring those foundations means ignoring the drivers of long-term returns. Some larger European investors and pension funds are beginning to take this seriously.
Do you notice a clear divide in (financial) outcomes today between frontrunner investors and traditional ones?
The early evidence does not show a clear advantage or disadvantage. We need to assess performance over five or ten years before drawing firm conclusions.
If you have a portfolio with different stocks from the wider market, by definition its performance will naturally differ. When it does better, people like it; when it does worse, they question the strategy. The challenge is to avoid judging long-term investing on quarterly or annual results. That can be difficult when you are accountable to pension beneficiaries, but short-term fluctuations are not enough to assess the approach.
Where do you see European markets heading over the next five to ten years?
That is difficult to answer, particularly given uncertainty around developments such as AI. I would focus on the choices a business can make today. Understanding its impact can help it anticipate changes that affect its future.
In our work, we used Volkswagen and Tesla to illustrate how the shift towards electric vehicles could affect company valuations. We expected growing demand for electric vehicles to benefit Tesla, while traditional carmakers that were slow to adapt would face risks to their valuations. Integrated value offered a way to explore what could happen, rather than a precise forecast.
That is also the thinking behind our futureproofing ratio, which divides a company’s integrated value by its financial value. A ratio above one points towards transition opportunities, while a ratio below one points towards transition risks. This can help companies decide how to adapt and give investors a clearer understanding of the business model’s long-term prospects.
The focus is on how a business can succeed in a changing real economy, rather than relying only on comparisons with other companies’ valuations.
Has your work with Staatsbosbeheer changed or challenged your views on how we evaluate natural ecosystems?
My role at Staatsbosbeheer is not really about valuation. I enjoy serving on its supervisory board, because it lets me see what is happening on the ground. Once a year, the board visits one of its sites.
Last year, for example, we walked through a forest, and someone from Staatsbosbeheer explained that the topsoil was completely dead: no microbes, no life. That was because of nitrogen deposition. The tree standing there would eventually die. Seeing the impact with your own eyes is quite powerful.
The focus is on putting ideas into practice. Staatsbosbeheer leases out a lot of land and is moving towards regenerative land use, with lower leases for farmers. We get to see how these changes work in practice.
Water management is another major issue in nature conservation. In the past, the question was how to drain water from the land. Now it is how to retain enough water for forests during dry periods and manage the water system. There are also questions about creating new forests and maintaining existing ones.
These decisions connect nature conservation with wider questions about land use, including where to build housing and roads. My main role is to encourage a long-term vision. The organisation has to deal with today’s challenges, but I always invite people to consider what their decisions will mean further into the future.
What do you hope to achieve in the coming 10 years through integrated value and your work with the Futureproofing Institute?
My hope is that responsible business becomes the standard, with integrated value as its compass. I would like integrated value to become the normal way of assessing companies, and a purely financial valuation to become the exception.
Ultimately, this is about the future of capitalism. Capitalism brings many good things, including new solutions. But if companies extract value irresponsibly while profits go to only a few people, the system is not sustainable. I want companies to help solve our societal challenges while making themselves more futureproof.
Companies have choices about how to move towards a sustainable planet. A journalist once asked whether a negative integrated value for Heineken, reflecting the harms associated with alcohol, meant it would necessarily remain negative the following year. My answer was that the company has a choice: it can sell less alcohol and more 0.0% beer. We often treat business models as fixed, but companies can change what they do. Integrated value helps us explore those choices and what they could mean for a company’s future. That is what makes this work exciting.
Do you have any advice for young people?
Stick to your guns. Science can be very complex, but I try to think logically. If you have developed a line of reasoning, do not give in to the idea that 'this is the way we do it'. Make your own choices and stick to them.
Question your organization’s logic but do it in a friendly way. You do not need to make life unnecessarily difficult for yourself, and you can still stay true to yourself. In the end, people appreciate honesty more than politically correct answers. Be thoughtful about how you express your views and follow your intuition.
Acknowledgements
We would like to sincerely thank Dirk Schoenmaker for sharing his time, expertise and perspective on integrated value. His work highlights how healthy social and ecological foundations underpin long-term financial returns, and how businesses and investors can help build a more sustainable economy. By bringing financial, social and environmental value together, he invites us to rethink how we measure success and consider the consequences of today’s decisions for future generations.